John Vano:
The pressure is getting to me... that, and just about all of our kids were in and out of the living room during the performances last night, so I didn't take notes as I usually do. That said, let me give you some "impressions" from last night on American Idol.
Syesha had a chance to make the finals, but she needed to define herself in a big way. I believe that her "Fever" performance was a calculated risk to remind us that she's the remaining woman. It was an attempt to rally the men to her side... not bad, but most men don't vote so you need to successfully show who you are to America in another way as well. I think this is where she failed. She's been a very good performer of late--different looks, entertaining moves, strong vocals... but who is she? She's not Syesha, but a chameleon, so I can't see her moving on.
The Davids have established themselves as a brand--long ago. Cook is the innovator/rocker with the subtle shrug to tell you he heard you, but maybe he doesn't care. The Marionette (Archuleta) is the young worker bee who keeps popping us with ballads. Who will America choose? Based on the demographics and season-long consistency, it looks like Archuleta will carry the day in the end. Cook was building momentum and I thought he could topple Archie, but unless Cook goes bongo next week--it should be a D.A. victory.
That said, I was most entertained last night by Syesha. Most enjoyed Cook's vocals (though even he fell short of his usual standard), and I felt that Archie put together another solid week (doesn't he always?) ... though he's coming back around on me these past two weeks and making me feel it.
PREDICTION: Syesha ends her journey. Cook and Archuleta go mano-y-mano in the finals.
--------
Carp was saving Narnia this week, so his commentary is limited. Though he also wore the Rastafarian wig and went 7-for-7 in softball.
1. David Cook
2. David Archuleta
3. Syesha Mercado
PREDICTION: It will be Archie the Puppet Boy vs. Cookie the Song Choreographer in the finals.