My rankings for this week's American Idol. These are not predictions, but assessments. I will predict stays and goes when we're in the final 12.
1. Allison Iraheta--Nicely done. I wonder why these young upstarts always sing Heart? She hit the right notes all the way through.
2. Megan Joy Corkrey--a voice as beautiful as her face. Nice expressiveness. Very likeable. I call her "Tatty."
3. Adam Lambert--Who's he channeling? Like a mix of Elvis, David Guest, and David Cook. A born performer, that's for certain. Could stick around for awhile.
4. Mishavonna Henson--I liked her voice and confidence. She sounded a little too much like the original artist... just a little more tweaking and she'd be perfect.
5. Jasmine Murray--Seems to have the high wattage star quality that's needed. Sings pretty good, though some of her notes came back hollow. Good energy.
6. Kai Kalama--He has a nice voice and can use it, but I don't see the American Idol when I listen to him.
7. Jesse Langseth--Forgettable. Poor song choice, too retro. Sang it well, but she won’t be staying.
8. Kris Allen--The early round guys always sing Michael Jackson... hmm? Had me thinking karaoke, though he had a better finish. Don't see this guy making bones as a performer.
9. Matt Breitzke--I didn't expect the type of song he did, but I think it fit him, though the performance was kinda boring.
10. Nick Mitchell--He sang his farewell song... telling us "goodbye" with those lyrics. How could anyone vote through such a nasally singer? Yes, even I could do that. Just think if he got voted through in favor of a real singer... then would you see the other contestants howling? Did hit a nice big note.
11. Matt Giraud--Some nice tones, but breathy and forced. Forgettable.
12. Jeanine Vailes--Whoa, not good, dog. Shrill, hollow, very impressionistic. At least she enjoyed herself.
Carp's rankings: 1) Adam Lambert, 2) Allison Iraheta <big dropoff from here> 3) Nick Mitchell (he's a breath of fresh air), 4) Kris Allen, 5) Megan Corkery, 6) Kai Kalama, 7) Mishavonna Henson, 8) Jesse Langseth, 9) Matt Breitzke, 10) Jeanine Vailes, 11) Jasmine Murray, 12) Matt Giraud.
