Fives: American Idol Report

Vano says: My personal rankings for the week

1. Danny -- he had me with the first note.
2. Adam -- tone down the strange, still he's good.
3. Kris -- against my instincts, I've grown to like him.
4. Allison -- got the chops, but she's not blowing us out anymore.
5. Matt -- Michelle Pfieffer alone should have a permit to sing this song

Bottom 3 (by voters): 5) Matt, 4) Allison, 3) Kris. Matt ends his journey.

-------------------

Carp says:I realize I am woefully behind Vano at this point but am humbly submitting my AI rankings for this week.

1. Danny Gokey -- His glasses were not working for me but he had a Rat Pack swagger according to the clueless Cara.

2. Adam Lambert -- He is our Michael Phelps declared Paula excitedly.  In light of Mr. Phelps recent pecadillos I don't think that is a title Adam needs.

3. Kris Allen -- A little rough on the falsetto but the girls were going wild.

4. Allison Iraheta -- She was looking "dope".  Perhaps she is the female Michael Phelps.

5. Matt Giraud -- Not a good sign when Jamie Foxx calls you back with a suggestion after squinting at him the entire time sang.

Should Go Home:  Matt Giraud

Will Go Home: Matt Giraud

Comments

[paulavano]

Yep...that's how I saw it too! I got goose bumps listening to Danny. That man can sing!

[Susan]

What did you guys think of Adam being in the bottom two? I was surprised, but glad to see it. Maybe America is not ready for their American Idol to be so "out" there?

[johnvano]

Totals going in: Vano 28, Carp 14.5

Results: Vano and Carp correctly placed Matt and Kris in the bottom 3 but missed Adam. He correctly guessed Matt going home = 5 points

Current totals: Vano 33, Carp 19.5